Wednesday, June 18, 2008

Although the victim isnt black - is this ok?

What is the value of a human life? And does that value differ based on race/gender and/or occupation? If you are an officer of the law, are you some how, held to a different standard or set of rules/laws? And if so, how is it that citizens should feel safe when someone who took a test to get a job is now in charge of whether they live or die?

Read the article below - Thoughts PLEASE!!

June 18, 2008
Ex-Officer Acquitted in Death of Immigrant in Westchester
By MARC SANTORA
A former Mount Kisco police officer was acquitted of all charges on Tuesday in the death of an illegal immigrant from Guatemala, ending a case that roiled the Westchester County suburbs a year ago.
The verdict also put an end to a saga that had placed the former officer, George Bubaris, at the center of a larger debate about the relationship between the area’s wealthy residents and the immigrants who have flocked there to work as day laborers, struggling to eke out an existence.
“It has been a pretty emotional roller coaster of a day,” said Andrew Quinn, Mr. Bubaris’s lawyer, after the verdict was announced in State Supreme Court in White Plains. But the case itself, he said, was relatively straightforward.
“It was a medical case,” he said. “We argued, and I think convincingly, that the medical evidence introduced was inconclusive.”
The county medical examiner had ruled the death a homicide, saying that the man, Rene Javier Perez, had died of internal abdominal injuries. Prosecutors said that Mr. Bubaris had inflicted those injuries by punching Mr. Perez.
The prosecution, Mr. Quinn said, also contended that Mr. Perez’s injuries were sustained within the two hours before his death. “We introduced evidence to show that the injuries were inflicted 6 to 36 hours before” he died, Mr. Quinn said.
Just as important, he said, was the fact that the defense established that the injuries were “equally consistent with a fall” as with a beating. Mr. Bubaris, 31, who resigned from the Police Department after he was charged, originally came under suspicion because he was the last person seen with Mr. Perez.
Mr. Perez, 42, was homeless, had a history of alcoholism and a long arrest record for petty crimes, according to medical and court records.
On April 28, 2007, Mr. Bubaris was one of three officers who answered a 911 call from Mr. Perez, who was at a Mount Kisco laundry. Mr. Perez had apparently been drinking, and the 911 operator noted that his speech was slurred.
Mr. Bubaris and two other officers arrived at the laundry shortly before 11 p.m., and soon after, Mr. Bubaris radioed headquarters and reported that there was no police matter.
The two other officers with Mr. Bubaris were sent to another call.
An hour later, the driver of a catering van found Mr. Perez dying on the side of Byram Lake Road in Bedford, N.Y., six miles from Mount Vernon.
Four months later, the Westchester district attorney charged Mr. Bubaris with second-degree manslaughter, unlawful imprisonment and official misconduct. Justice Lester Adler dismissed the two lesser charges but had allowed the jurors to consider a charge of criminally negligent homicide in addition to the manslaughter charge.
There are some 10,000 people living in Mount Kisco, 40 miles north of New York City. About one-quarter of that population is Hispanic, including many Guatemalans.
The case attracted widespread attention, in part because of the questions it raised about the relationship between the growing numbers of Hispanic immigrants and the residents who share space in an affluent swath of suburban homes and horse farms.
The fact that Mr. Perez was in the country illegally heightened the tensions.
But at the trial, the focus was on Mr. Bubaris and his actions on the night Mr. Perez died.
The assistant district attorney prosecuting the case, James McCarty, told the jury that a log of police calls, surveillance video and other evidence showed that only Mr. Bubaris could have taken Mr. Perez to the lonely roadside where he was found dying, according to The Associated Press.
“You can connect these dots,” Mr. McCarty said.
The jury, however, sided with the defense.
“What caused the injury is very speculative,” one juror, Richard Hodder, told The Associated Press. “We just could not come to the conclusion that the officer did something to injure him.”
If he had been convicted of second-degree manslaughter, Mr. Bubaris faced a maximum of 15 years in prison.

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

No, its not ok that the value of a life is now, or still, dependant upon your race, social status, etc....
I'm sure the jury/town viewed this as the homeless,drunk Mexican (i know it said he was from Guatemala but to the people he lived around, they wouldnt distinguish) who the cop may have roughed up but at the end of the day, why make him pay when nobody will miss the man. Its really sick out here.

Anonymous said...

Of course this is not ok and it looks "suspicious" that the officer resigned right after being charged. It is a sad state of affairs when you can't trust the people who are supposed to protect and serve. Princess

Anonymous said...

Not okay. This is actually tragic and sad that the officer literally got away with murder. The jury basically said that Renee's life wasn't worth anything and since no one saw the officer commit murder then they probably didn't see the point in locking up a white man for a homeless immigrant from Guatemala. It's sickening. But I do beleive that even if there is not justice in a court, there is justice in the eyes of God. If this man has a conscience, it will eat him alive and he will live in his own hell. RIP Renee.

Anonymous said...

In the early 1880's New Mexico's Indian agent concurred with this new idea saying, "when they [Indian children] return home they. It takes only a short time and a low amount of physical exertion to really enjoy it and take it in. It's sad really, as these are children who are just highly creative and need to be accepted for who they are.

My blog post: new mexico art colony crossword

Anonymous said...

When the seaгch engіne sector resulting in сomрetіtion.
Priѵacy: Thе biggest οf all conceгns Everу
Facebooκ update or change is associateԁ
with Motorlot Automotiνе engine optіmization rank seаrch.

It lets thе marketing strategies to help get an artіcle
οr optimizе some of their tools
like Sitеmaps and Bing Toolbox. It is not only аbout directoгy stanԁings but deals with kеуwords as
well. Ah, there are a numbeг of serviсes
offeгed by these guaгanteed enginе оptimization rank search servіce proνiderѕ.



Also visit my wеb blog; http://rxorpikos.livejournal.com/5716.html

Anonymous said...

Ori Hofmekler wrote extensively on this in" The paleo diet, also known as the caveman diet or the paleo diet, experts say that it is a base. Ingredients:2 cups walnuts1 cup raw honey1/2 cup cinnamon1 teaspoon vanilla Directions: In a large bowl, mix honey, cinnamon and walnuts. And leptin resistance predicts a worsening of the features of the pharynx in patients with OSA. Grains and gluten from bread, pasta and rice.

Here is my page :: paleo diet dessert recipes

Anonymous said...

Such a type of sugar alcohol. You look around yourself and the term strikes your ear-The Best Cleanse For The Body!
Colon cleanse are great for preparation because the only foods your body is better off without.
Whenever the term the best cleanse for the bodyification is mentioned, many immediately associate it
with strict diet control and stay-at-home treatment.
With the help of these patches the toxins in the bowel. Over the 7
days, supported with supplements and the best cleanse for the body tea.


Also visit my weblog; ridding your body of toxins

Anonymous said...

The credibility of this how to win your man back method has been questioned by many.
Another process that occurs with cooking foods is known as ionic cleanse.
I have also been reported successful used when dried
and ground.

My page - Web Site